Northern Ireland news

Rugby rape trial: Victims' support group calls for review into how trials are conducted

The Dublin Rape Crisis Centre said all parties in the rape trial were "subjected to questioning on the most intimate and private aspects of their lives in a way that was inefficient and cruel"
John Monaghan

THE trial of the Ulster Rugby players Paddy Jackson and Stuart Olding should lead to a general review into how cases of alleged sexual offences are conducted, a victims' support group has said.

The Dublin Rape Crisis Centre (DRCC) said that all parties were "subjected to questioning on the most intimate and private aspects of their lives in a way that was inefficient and cruel".

A spokeswoman for the DRCC said that complainants should be allowed legal support to prepare themselves for being questioned by defence teams.

"In order to achieve the law’s legitimate aim of trying to rock her evidence, she (the complainant in this case) was put into a grilling, relentless legal process, unrepresented, for six days.

"We are concerned that the reporting on this case will further deter those who might otherwise report rape," the spokeswoman said.

The DRCC has also called for members of the public to be barred from attending rape trials and for neither complainant nor accused to be named until after the trial is over, as is the case in the Republic.

"This would have prevented the extra pressure caused by a packed public gallery and attendance of the defendant’s team mates, Irish rugby captain Rory Best and Ian Henderson.

"While there are some difficulties with our system, this case shows that it is a more humane system as the naming of high profile defendants was a significant factor in the interest of the press and public in this case," added the spokeswoman for the Centre.

Nexus NI, which supports victims of sexual abuse and violence, said that the trial had "increased dialogue around sexual violence; we now need to ensure these conversations continue and that the necessary support is provided to victims."

Alliance deputy leader Stephen Farry MLA said that the complainant in such cases was often subject to "more attention" and a more balanced approach was needed.

"Compared to other types of crime, more attention tends to fall on the actions and comments of complainants, and the criminal justice system needs to ensure the right approach is found, focusing on the relevant issues while preserving the integrity of justice," said Mr Farry.

Anyone who has been affected by sexual violence can contact Nexus, The Rowan, Sexual Assault Referral Centre on 9442 4340 and  the 24 Hour Domestic and Sexual Violence Helpline on 0808 802 1414.

Read More

Paddy Jackson and Stuart Olding found not guilty of rape
Allison Morris: There were even giggles in the public gallery as graphic details of alleged rape were read out (Premium)
Alleged victim's name was posted on comments section of an online news site
Relatives clasped each others' hands and openly wept as verdicts delivered
Victims' support group calls for review into how trials are conducted
Allison Morris: I have two daughters and would not encourage them to go through retraumatising rape trial (Premium)
One of the most expensive rape trials in UK judicial history
'I Believe Her' rallies planned across Ireland
Ireland rugby captain Rory Best's decision to attend court on day two of the rape trial provoked a storm of criticism
About the rugby rape trial judge Patricia Smyth
PSNI says woman at centre of trial 'upset and disappointed' at verdict
Paddy Jackson's lawyers say status as famous sportsman 'drove the decision to prosecute'
Paddy Jackson's lawyers call for crackdown on 'vile' social media commentary during criminal proceedings
Paddy Jackson and Stuart Olding 'will continue to be relieved of all duties' as review takes place
Stuart Olding faces major battle to return to pinnacle of his sport
Paddy Jackson had unwavering support from his parents
Stuart Olding: I deeply regret events of that evening... I am sorry for the hurt caused to the complainant
Blane McIlroy admitted being prone to exaggeration
Rory Harrison had been working in Australia before he flew home to stand trial
Video: Paddy Jackson thanks judge and jury for fair trial
Public Prosecution Service: 'Ultimately right' rugby rape case was brought to trial

Alliance deputy leader Stephen Farry MLA also backed calls for a review of the handling of cases of alleged sex crimes. Picture by Hugh Russell

Enjoy reading the Irish News?

Subscribe now to get full access

Northern Ireland news