Ask Fiona: My granddaughter is only 16 but is allowed to stay out until midnight

Columnist and trained counsellor Fiona Caine offers her perspective to a concerned sister, and a mother who has fallen out with her daughter.

Raising children isn't easy, but there's nothing more annoying than someone telling you how to raise them
Fiona Caine


MY DAUGHTER and I had a terrible row a couple of weeks ago about whether she should be allowing her daughter (my granddaughter) the freedom to go out with boys.

She's only 16, but she's allowed to stay out until midnight. There's even been occasions where she's stayed with her boyfriend's parents.

I've tried to talk to my daughter since, but she is avoiding my calls and isn't returning my messages. Why can't she see that I only have her daughter's best interests at heart? I really don't like the atmosphere between us now.



You may be concerned about your granddaughter, but I don't think you are showing much support for your daughter. Raising children isn't easy (as I'm sure you know) but there's nothing more annoying than someone telling you how to raise them.

At 16, your granddaughter is more than old enough to have a boyfriend and, providing she is sensible, be allowed to stay out. You think of her as a child but you're forgetting, she's old enough to get married.

Your daughter has had to make difficult decisions about her daughter – if she is too restrictive she risks alienating her. She has obviously decided that her daughter and the boyfriend are sensible, and she may know and trust his parents too.

If you genuinely want to heal this rift, you are going to have to re-establish contact with your daughter, and if she won't answer your calls, I suggest you write or perhaps visit her.



MY 17-YEAR-OLD nephew has been a difficult lad for as long as I can remember. However, it wasn't until last month that my sister took him to see a specialist and learned that he has schizophrenia.

He's now undertaking some kind of assessment but, in the meantime, he has been prescribed medication to calm him down. My sister isn't handling the situation well, although most of the time she tries to pretend that nothing is wrong.

I know that she's been crying a lot and is very depressed by what has happened – how on earth she is going to cope with this for the rest of his life I do not know. I'm there for her as much as I can be, but I'd like to do more.

Other than her doctor, are there any other sources of help I can investigate for her?



People who have complex mental health issues are usually entered into a care plan known as a "Care Programme Approach" – the first stage of which is the assessment. It sounds as if your nephew is still in the early stages of this programme, so what might help your sister is to understand exactly what it involves.

I would suggest you steer her to the NHS website ( as there is a huge amount of information on schizophrenia, and also treatment options.

Sadly, and in spite of a number of brilliant campaigns, there is still some stigma attached to any form of mental illness, and I suspect this is what causes your sister to pretend everything is fine. Unfortunately, schizophrenia is particularly poorly misunderstood and there are myths around about "split personalities" and a fear that people with the condition are dangerous.

Whilst your sister may already be receiving some support from mental health professionals, one of the most important things she needs from you is acceptance.

So many people are afraid of being ostracised when a diagnosis like this is given to a family member. Your nephew has a complex medical condition and he will need help and support to deal with it - but it can be dealt with.

Treatment usually involves a mix of medication and therapy and it's tailored to the individual, as each case is different. In most cases, it means a use of anti-psychotic medicines and cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT). Once this is all in place, there is every chance your nephew will be quite well day-to-day.

Having said that, he may have periods when he relapses; his symptoms could return but, the help, support and treatment should help reduce the impact schizophrenia has on his daily life. For your sister, though, there will be a huge adjustment to make.

It's natural for her to be upset, confused and probably angry, because any diagnosis of an ongoing condition changes things. The child she thought she had is, somehow, different, and her expectations for him will have to change too.

This is not the end of the world – even though she may feel it is at the moment – so please continue to offer her and her family all the love and support you can.

Once the result of the assessment is known, everyone will be in a much better position to think about what happens next. For the future, both your sister and her son will need help and encouragement to come to terms with this diagnosis and what it means.

Finding out all you can will help you feel positive and helpful while they go through a period of adjustment. Rethink ( also provides a wealth of information on many different types of mental illness, their treatments and what it means to live with them. It also offers advice on how to access services and an individual's legal rights.

:: If you have a problem you need help with, email Fiona by writing to for advice. All letters are treated in complete confidence and, to protect this privacy, Fiona is unable to pass on your messages to other readers. Fiona regrets that she cannot enter into personal correspondence.

Enjoy reading the Irish News?

Subscribe now to get full access


Today's horoscope


See a different horoscope: