There have been calls for the sacking of British Home Secretary Suella Braverman after she was accused of “deliberately stoking division” by using Northern Ireland as a point of comparison to characterise pro-Palestinian demonstrations planned for the UK as “hate marches”.
SDLP leader Colum Eastwood called for the removal of Ms Braverman from her position as he branded the comments as “aggressive ignorance”.
@SuellaBraverman is a Pound Shop Enoch Powell. And she can leave us out of it too.
— Colum Eastwood (@columeastwood) November 8, 2023
Writing in The Times, Mrs Braverman claimed “hate marchers” intend to use the Armistice Day protest as a “show of strength”.
The Home Secretary also characterised alleged reports that organisers of Saturday’s march were linked to Hamas as “disturbingly reminiscent of Ulster”.
Mrs Braverman said: “I do not believe that these marches are merely a cry for help for Gaza.
“They are an assertion of primacy by certain groups — particularly Islamists — of the kind we are more used to seeing in Northern Ireland.
“Also disturbingly reminiscent of Ulster are the reports that some of Saturday’s march group organisers have links to terrorist groups, including Hamas.”
Read More
- Braverman takes aim at police over pro-Palestinian protests
- Braverman lifestyle choice comments ‘nonsense' says homeless charity founder
In a statement on Thursday, Mr Eastwood said: “The Home Secretary’s comments in an article in The Times today are so far removed from reality that it is impossible to come to any determination other than she is deliberately stoking division to bolster her own brand among the Conservative Party’s right wing.
“It’s honestly like reading a pound shop Enoch Powell piece.
“The comments comparing the proposed Armistice Day protests against the appalling bombardment of civilians in Gaza with the marching tradition in Northern Ireland are an exercise in what can only be described as aggressive ignorance; ignorance of the conditions faced by the civilian population in Gaza, ignorance of the role of the Met police, ignorance of the complex history and traditions of marching and protest in Northern Ireland.
“She has managed to offend just about everyone – no mean feat in a divided society.
Analysis: Whether this is aimed at Protestant Loyal Orders or the Catholic Civil Rights Movement, it demonstrates breathtaking ignorance re. Northern Ireland’s history, is highly offensive and inflammatory, not least because there’s no power-sharing government in place right now. https://t.co/lsYmb66jCF
— David Blevins (@skydavidblevins) November 9, 2023
“The comments are far below the standard that should be expected from a senior government minister. The only appropriate action now is her removal from office but given the systemic weakness of this government, I wouldn’t be at all surprised if she remained.”
Orange Order Grand Secretary, the Rev Mervyn Gibson, said Ms Braverman should be more careful in her choice of language.
Speaking to The Irish News, he said: "One thing the Home Secretary could do is simply to clarify which parades she meant.
"I know there's some spin and briefings that she was referring to dissident republican parades, if that's the case then that's all she has to say.
"A clarification from the Home Secretary would certainly be welcome."
He added: "We don't recognise our parades as the one she's referring to.
"In fact we have written to her about the parades this weekend and her stance on those supporting Palestine and Hamas.
"We support her stance on those particular issues for Remembrance Weekend.
"But, she's been clumsy in what she's said."
Rev Gibson said the letter from the Orange Order to Ms Braverman had made clear they differentiate between recognising the suffering of ordinary Palestinians and support for Hamas fighters.
"We've made it clear that any protests this weekend shouldn't clash with remembrance events," he said.
"The nation is remembering those who served and died.
"We'll be remembering Muslims, Sikhs, all faiths and none.
"Nothing should interfere with remembrance weekend and that's the difficulty, it appears, as some want to gain extra publicity but also clash with Remembrance Day services.
"Not them all, but there will be elements (in those groups) that need stopped."
Matt Carthy, a Sinn Féin TD, also criticised the remarks on BBC radio: “Suella Braverman has about as much knowledge about Ireland as she seems to have on the situation in Palestine.
“Clearly, I would argue that if British government ministers are in the frame of mind where they want to talk about Ireland, and in particular the North, the frame of mind they should be in is ensuring that the DUP return to Stormont and that we actually get the Executive up and running.”
Responding to the Home Secretary’s piece, Labour MP Jess Phillips said: “Braverman makes our country less safe. Not satisfied with inflaming tensions in London she thought she’d also light a match under Northern Ireland relations. No right-thinking prime minister would stand by her, let alone approve her copy.”
Former Northern Ireland secretary Lord Peter Hain said the remarks were an attack on Orange Order marches.
He said: “Why on earth is this gratuitously offensive Home Secretary meddling in Northern Ireland affairs with her ignorant attack on Orange Order marches by traditional unionists?
Baffling reference to Northern Ireland from Suella Braverman in her Times Op-Ed. By presumably claiming that Orange Order marches are “assertions of primacy” with links to terrorist organisations, is she and her govt trying to scupper the talks with the DUP? Odd in the extreme. https://t.co/DDvP1Jc9n4
— Cormac Moore (@cormacmoore) November 9, 2023
“She should stick to her day job and stop her scatter gun headline-grabbing attacks on all and sundry.”
