Northern Ireland

Bovine TB compensation consultation responses to be considered by minister

The proposal is to reduce the level to 90% in the first year of implementation and 75% a year later.

A picture of cows on a path leading towards a mountain
The DUP said a reduction in compensation would create financial hardship for farmers and their families. PICTURE: Yui Mok/PA Wire (Yui Mok/PA)

Agriculture Minister Andrew Muir has said he will consider consultation responses to a proposal to cut the rate of compensation for cattle with bovine tuberculosis.

While the Stormont Executive was suspended, the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs launched a public consultation on cutting the compensation rate, which is currently on a full market value basis.

The proposal is to reduce the level to 90% in the first year of implementation and 75% a year later.

The consultation closed on Friday.

Mr Muir said the budget settlement his department receives will “determine an awful lot in terms of what I can and can’t do”.



“I do not wish to change the compensation rate, but if the budget is slashed to the effect that I cannot statutorily undertake my duties then I will be left with no other place to move,” he told MLAs on Monday.

Andrew Muir said analysis of the consultation responses was under way
Andrew Muir said analysis of the consultation responses was under way (Liam McBurney/PA)

During questions for Mr Muir in the Stormont Assembly on Monday, DUP MLA William Irwin said a reduction in compensation would create financial hardship for farmers and their families.

Mr Muir responded by saying that Northern Ireland Secretary Chris Heaton-Harris had directed the department to consult on the proposals while Stormont was suspended.

He said his officials have started the process of analysing the responses to that consultation and he will consider a detailed summary when it is prepared to him.

Mr Muir went on to say he is “acutely aware” of the devastating impact of bovine TB and the financial challenges for farmers and farming families.

“I therefore appreciate that any proposal which suggests reducing TB compensation will be extremely difficult for the farming community,” he said.

“The budget settlement for the next financial year will have a significant bearing on what my department can do in this and many other areas.”

He added: “That was not my proposal, it was the Secretary of State’s proposal to consult about reducing the compensation rate to 90% and then 75%.

“That was a consequence of this place not sitting and us not being able to make our own policy decisions in relation to this.

“I’m determined to bring a fresh approach to this issue, to see what way we can have a sustainable future for our farming community and also then for my department, the focus is upon the farming community.”

Mr Muir said one of the first tasks he has asked new chief veterinary officer Brian Dooher to do is take a fresh look at the issue and provide a new way forward.