Opinion

William Scholes: Speaker row a symptom of shambles at Stormont

William Scholes

William Scholes

William has worked at The Irish News since 2002. His areas of interest include religion and motoring.

Stormont speaker Robin Newton offered advice but denies being an adviser to Charter NI
Stormont speaker Robin Newton offered advice but denies being an adviser to Charter NI Stormont speaker Robin Newton offered advice but denies being an adviser to Charter NI

TAKING my customary quick flick through this newspaper one morning last week, I found myself stopped mid-riffle by an odd headline.

It made just as little sense the second time.

This, I feel contractually obliged to add, was not because of any error in the wording or spelling.

Further investigation revealed that it accurately reflected the content of the story it related to.

"Satisfaction rating high for secretary of state" it read. Some mistake, surely? "Dissatisfaction" would be more like it, I thought.

But no; according to the story, Conservative Party members reckon that secretary of shire James Brokenstate is doing such a great job that he has the sixth highest approval rating of all its cabinet members and senior elected representatives.

Let that sink in for a moment. Mr Brokenshire, the covert secretary of state who has made zero impact during his time in Northern Ireland, is the sixth best-regarded Conservative politician on the planet.

Given the three-ring circus that the Conservative Party has become, this is a bit like coming sixth in a height competition contested by the Seven Dwarfs.

However, Mr Brokenshire still managed to find himself placed ahead of people you may even have heard of, like Boris Johnson, Philip Hammond and Theresa May.

Each of them would at least stand a chance of being recognised by the average punter on Royal Avenue.

But how many people would be able to identify Mr Brokenshire? An image of an empty car stopping at the kerb to allow the secretary of state to get out comes to mind.

The secretary of state's approval rating is yet more evidence that the Conservative Party has not a clue, and cares even less, about Northern Ireland.

How else can you rationalise anyone finding satisfaction in Mr Brokenshire's performance?

To say it has been lacklustre is unfair to both lack and lustre. At least when they are conjoined they make sense, unlike, say, 'glide' and 'path', a favoured aphorism of the secretary of shire.

But we live in times when nothing makes sense, at least in the logical way you might try to explain things to a primary school child.

Northern Ireland has, for example, assembly members but no assembly.

And even though there is no assembly, Stormont somehow still needs a speaker to run its proceedings.

As anything more modest would be regarded as an insult, being speaker to a non-existent assembly attracts an annual salary of £87,000. Naturally.

Current holder of this value-for-money post is a DUP gentleman called Robin Newton.

You had probably never heard of Mr Newton before recent, erm, controversies.

He was, for a time, a junior minister in the Office of Deputy First Minister and First Minister - ah, halcyon days... - but that is the political equivalent of going on a witness protection scheme.

Having risen without trace to the office of speaker, Mr Newton has gone on to prove himself to be a brass-necked casuist hairsplitter in the finest tradition of his party.

Last year he found himself mixed up in an inconvenient row.

Questions were being asked about his role in lobbying for funding on behalf of the UDA-linked community group Charter NI. Charter NI, you may recall, is the Social Investment Fund wing of the 'homeland security' unit run by alleged UDA suit Dee Stitt.

Mr Newton had failed to officially declare the extent of his involvement in Charter NI and, in the best North Korean spirit of the DUP, he decided to use his powers as speaker to block questions about the group's funding.

He also explained that while he had indeed offered advice to Charter NI, this in no way amounted to him being an adviser to the group.

This was patent nonsense then and looks doubly ridiculous now.

Charter NI documents, put into the public domain by BBC Spotlight this week, repeatedly refer to Mr Newton's significant role in the group.

Mr Newton now stands accused of misleading the assembly over the extent of his association with Charter NI.

His position was already untenable. He had made a hames of assembly proceedings last December when he allowed Arlene Foster, then first minister, to make a statement about the Renewable Heat Incentive scheme without the support of deputy first minister Martin McGuinness.

But making a bigger hames out of a small hames is Stormont's stock in trade.

Mr Newton's difficulties are simply symptomatic of the malaise that already lay at the heart of Stormont before it all went belly up.

It is tempting to lay the blame for all this at the door of the DUP alone.

And while there is something uniquely boorish, entitled and obnoxious about the DUP - as I've observed before, it is the crocodile-baiting, yoghurt-currying, yo-hoing, Arlene's-on-fire chanting, RHI-denying, Red Sky's-all-right-Nelson's-delight, Nama-mia-here-I-go-again, buck eejitistical, Spad-tastic, FOI-dodging and Sif-it-makes-you-happy party - it has been matched stride-for-stride by Sinn Féin.

The DUP and Sinn Féin duopoly has consistently shown itself incapable of working for the good of all.

Never mind, then, who the speaker is; why should we even care whether Stormont can stir itself back into existence?