Northern Ireland

British Armed forces chief concerned by new Troubles investigations

DUP MP Gavin Robinson joins protesters at a rally at Belfast City Hall against the prosecution of British Army veterans. Picture by Hugh Russell
DUP MP Gavin Robinson joins protesters at a rally at Belfast City Hall against the prosecution of British Army veterans. Picture by Hugh Russell DUP MP Gavin Robinson joins protesters at a rally at Belfast City Hall against the prosecution of British Army veterans. Picture by Hugh Russell

The outgoing head of the armed forces has said he is deeply uncomfortable at the prospect of military veterans facing investigation for actions which occurred during the Troubles in Northern Ireland.

Air Chief Marshal Sir Stuart Peach - who steps down as Chief of the Defence Staff next week - said it was a political decision as to whether there should be a statute of limitations on inquiries into past events.

But speaking at the Policy Exchange think tank in London, he made clear that he was concerned at the way such investigations could play out.

His intervention came after Defence Minister Tobias Ellwood broke ranks with the official British government position over the weekend to back calls for a time limit for investigations into historical events.

A current consultation document issued by Northern Ireland Secretary Karen Bradley on dealing with the legacy of the Troubles does not include provision for a statute of limitations, to the anger of many Conservative MPs.

Asked if he thought there should be a statute of limitations, Air Chief Marshal Peach said: "That question as posed is a political decision.

"My position as Chief of the Defence Staff is very clear. We in the Ministry of Defence will continue to support the veterans with legal and other support. That is an absolutely unequivocal clear position.

"If you ask me as Stuart Peach as I depart as Chief of the Defence Staff, I am deeply uncomfortable about some of this as to the way in which it could be interpreted.

"I am uncomfortable with what is happening. It is for the government to decide things like statute of limitations and how the law is understood and framed.

"As Chief of Defence Staff all I am allowed to do within my terms and conditions is to insure - which I give you my word that we do insure - that our veterans are properly supported if they are called forward for due process."

Tobias Ellwood MP has said he would have liked to have seen a statute of limitations for veterans included in the current legacy consultation.
Tobias Ellwood MP has said he would have liked to have seen a statute of limitations for veterans included in the current legacy consultation. Tobias Ellwood MP has said he would have liked to have seen a statute of limitations for veterans included in the current legacy consultation.

He added: "It is not just about one place. The way, through common law, this could play out makes me discomfited as well as uncomfortable about the plight veterans might find themselves in."

Mark Francois, a Conservative member of Commons Defence Committee, said there was growing dismay at the prospect of veterans facing investigation over events which may have occurred almost half a century ago.

"A number of us on the Defence Select Committee are extremely concerned about how this is playing out in practice - the idea that what a young man did in a ditch in Crossmaglen in 1971 is now going to be played over and crawled over nearly 50 years later, partly at the behest of Sinn Fein," he said.

In his valedictory address, Air Chief Marshal Peach said the forces would have to be more flexible in their approach to recruitment if they were to attract the skills they needed for the future - such as relaxing the medical requirements for cyber warfare specialists.

"I am quite relaxed about having cyber warriors who don't deploy overseas. Their work is here. I am quite relaxed about medical conditions being relaxed because they are not deploying overseas. We need to think about this in a different way," he said.

Responding to Air Chief Marshal Peach's comments, Theresa May's official spokesman said: "The prime minister has been clear that the current system in Northern Ireland is flawed and isn't working.

"It needs to change to ensure that our armed forces are not unfairly treated.

"We owe a vast debt of gratitude to the heroism and bravery of the soldiers and police officers who upheld the rule of law and were themselves accountable to it - something which will always set them apart from and above terrorists who during the Troubles were responsible for the deaths of hundreds of members of the security forces.

"What we are absolutely clear on, however, is that we cannot countenance any proposal where amnesties would be provided to those terrorists."