News

Panama papers: David Cameron faces fresh row over £200,000 gift from his mother

Ian and Mary Cameron, the parents of British prime minister David Cameron. Picture by Johnny Green, Press Association
Ian and Mary Cameron, the parents of British prime minister David Cameron. Picture by Johnny Green, Press Association Ian and Mary Cameron, the parents of British prime minister David Cameron. Picture by Johnny Green, Press Association

DAVID Cameron faced a fresh row over his personal finances after Downing Street revealed he had been given a £200,000 gift by his mother following his father's death which could potentially avoid inheritance tax.

Number 10 said that the two payments of £100,000 in 2011 came on top of the £300,000 Mr Cameron inherited from his father Ian as the British prime minister's mother Mary attempted to "balance" the sums received by their children.

The information was revealed as part of an unprecedented release of information about the prime minister's finances, which showed that he paid more than £400,000 in tax on an income of more than £1 million over six years from 2009 to 2015.

The payments by Mary Cameron to her son in May and July 2011 were given tax free, and will only become liable to inheritance tax of up to 40 per cent if the Prime Minister's mother dies within seven years of handing over the money.

The release of the information by Downing Street followed the furore over the Panama Papers data leak and the revelation that Mr Cameron and his wife Samantha made a £19,000 profit on shares in an offshore trust set up by the prime minister's father.

The prime minister has been angered by the focus on his father's offshore business interests, insisting it was a "fundamental misconception" that the Blairmore Holdings trust had been set up to avoid tax.

But Labour seized on his father's offshore business links to question the source of Mr Cameron's inheritance and the gift from his mother.

A Labour Party spokesman said: "The week started with a moral crisis at the heart of the Tory party and has now ended with a scandal at the very top of government.

"The prime minister has been forced to admit that not only had he benefited from a company that paid no tax in 30 years, but that he may pay no tax on any benefits potentially gained from the same company.

"David Cameron can't hide any more, he needs to come to Parliament on Monday and put the record straight."

The information released by Number 10, in a schedule drawn up by accountants, showed the prime minister had a taxable income of more than £200,000 in 2014-15 and paid almost £76,000 in tax.

The figures show that, on top of his income as prime minister, his 50 per cent share of the rental income on the Camerons' family home in London amounted to £46,899, he received £9,834 in taxable expenses from the Tory party and £3,052 in interest on savings in a high street bank.

The figures reveal that when he first entered Downing Street in 2010 he benefited from a £20,000 tax-free allowance as part of his £142,500 salary, although in subsequent years he did not take advantage of the long-standing perk available to occupants of Number 10.

The information shows that Mr Cameron earned enough to benefit from the cut in the top rate of tax from 50p to 45p.

The cut, announced in 2012 for people earning more than £150,000, came into effect in April 2013.

Mr Cameron said he was publishing the information to be "completely open and transparent" about his financial affairs.

The disclosure came after he admitted botching the handling of the row over his finances, telling Tory activists it had "not been a great week".

The tax return figures show that in 2009-10, while leader of the opposition, Mr Cameron paid £43,483 income tax on a total taxable income of £129,225.

In 2010-11, after entering Downing Street, he paid £56,155 on a taxable income of £157,286 - benefiting from the little-known £20,000 tax-free "prime ministerial expenses deduction".

In 2011-12 his income rose to £200,919, boosted by his share of the rental income from the Notting Hill home vacated by the Camerons when they moved in to Downing Street, and he paid £77,987 in tax.

In 2012-13 Mr Cameron paid £72,472 tax on an income of £189,506; in 2013-14 he paid £76,288 on his £200,735 income.

Although Mr Cameron's gross salary as prime minister stood at £142,500 between 2010 and 2015, the variations in the taxable amount came through the way his pension contributions were treated and the different approaches taken to the £20,000 tax-free allowance.

The prime minister voluntarily cancelled out the allowance by declaring the equivalent amount as taxable income between 2011-12 and 2013-14 before waiving it entirely from 2014-15.

The figures show that the Camerons receive rent of more than £90,000 a year on the Notting Hill property.

Mr Cameron's 50 per cent share of the net rental income, minus expenses, was £45,041 in 2011-12, £46,700 in 2012-13, £47,764 in 2013-14 and £46,899 last year.

Interest from his high street savings accounts amounted to £26 in 2009-10, £87 in 2010-11, £365 in 2011-12 before rising to £2,701 in 2012-13, £6,681 in 2013-14 and £3,052 in 2014-15.

Mr Cameron's savings benefited from the sale of £72,000 of shares when he entered No 10, with the gains on some shares wiped out by losses on others, resulting in a capital loss of £2,507, and around £40,000 in cash from an account with a stockbroker.

Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn said he would publish his own tax return "very, very soon" and insisted there were "no surprises there" .

Mr Corbyn said more people in public life should publish their tax returns and suggested the Prime Minister still had questions to answer about his finances, particularly in the period before he entered No 10.

He told BBC One's Andrew Marr Show: "I want to see the papers. We need to know what he's actually returned as a tax return, we need to know why he put this money overseas in the first place and whether he made anything out of it or not before 2010 when he became prime minister.

"These are questions that he must answer. I think there is a question for Parliament there, there is a question for Parliamentary standards to question him on this.

"There is a question - big questions - that have to be put to him by Parliament and that surely is the function of Parliament."

He said the rules over inheritance tax may need to be looked at following the disclosure about the gift from Mr Cameron's mother.

"She has done that and that is within the rules, providing of course the person giving the money lives for more than seven years - and obviously we hope she does.

"The issue is one that it does actually reduce the level of inheritance tax that is available for the Exchequer as a whole.

"Is there a case for looking at inheritance tax rules? Possibly, but I think what's more important this week is actually looking at the whole question of tax havens, of British dependent territories, of the way in which huge sums of money are placed in these havens to evade tax in Britain.

"There's a moral case: if you earn money, you pay tax. If you earn a lot of money, you pay more tax.

"Non-payment of tax means underfunding of public services as a whole, that's what the Panama Papers have shown. The moral case has to be made."

A Tory minister said Mr Cameron would have to "demonstrate and build up" trust with the British public following the row over the Panama Papers.

Defence minister Penny Mordaunt, who is on the opposing side of the European Union referendum argument to the prime minister, told BBC One's Sunday Politics: "I don't think it's damaged his credibility. I think - I don't have any other insights other than you do, but I don't think he has done anything wrong.

"I think what this is about is trust. And he has to now demonstrate and build up that trust and rapport with the general public."

Asked if the Prime Minister had lost her trust, she replied: "I think that this will raise questions ... about politicians publishing further information about themselves, and I think although I understand arguments around privacy and security, if that is what the electorate require of their elected officials, I think that's what will have to happen."

Justice minister and supporter of the Vote Leave campaign Dominic Raab argued it "seems crystal clear not only that he's (Mr Cameron) not done anything illegal, but he's not behaved improperly in any way".

He told Sky News' Murnaghan programme: "Frankly some of the personalised attacks on him, on his father, have been deeply unsavoury. Jeremy Corbyn came in saying as leader of the Labour Party he was going to introduce a kinder politics and yet he's been whipping up a mob mentality and engaging and leading these attacks, whipping up Labour MPs who, some of them are behaving like, frankly, hyenas.

"I think it's grotesque hypocrisy given what he's said and really it's just about scoring political points, there's no substance to any of this at all in relation to trying to suggest the PM has done anything wrong."