The author Sir Philip Pullman has called for the commemorative Brexit 50p to be boycotted for not having an Oxford comma.
The coin, which enters circulation on January 31, reads: “Peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations.”
An Oxford comma is used after the penultimate item in a list of three or more items, so would be placed after the word “prosperity”.
His Dark Materials author Sir Philip wrote on Twitter that the omission meant the coin should “be boycotted by all literate people”.
The 'Brexit' 50p coin is missing an Oxford comma, and should be boycotted by all literate people.
— Philip Pullman (@PhilipPullman) January 26, 2020
Stig Abell, the editor of the Times Literary Supplement, also condemned the coin’s punctuation.
He tweeted: “Not perhaps the only objection, but the lack of a comma after ‘prosperity’ is killing me.”
Not perhaps the only objection, but the lack of a comma after “prosperity” is killing me. pic.twitter.com/ZCN6Zt45cH
— Stig Abell (@StigAbell) January 26, 2020
However user @TychoNestoris1 replied: “Be gone with your American serial comma nonsense!”
Also known as a serial comma, the punctuation mark derives its common name from its use in by the Oxford University Press (OUP).
On its use, the OUP’s style guide states: “In a list of three or more items, insert a comma before the ‘and’ or ‘or’.”
Author and economics commentator Frances Coppola said the punctuation was not essential for the new 50p.
As all literate people know, the Oxford comma is entirely optional. But it offends both in its presence and its absence. Whatever the choice, someone will think it wrong. There could not be a better commemoration of Brexit. https://t.co/ZI2ashBi6W
— (((🕷Frances Coppola))) (@Frances_Coppola) January 27, 2020
Responding to Sir Philip, she tweeted: “As all literate people know, the Oxford comma is entirely optional.
“But it offends both in its presence and its absence.
“Whatever the choice, someone will think it wrong.
“There could not be a better commemoration of Brexit.”
Sir Philip noted the debate was not a matter of grammar but orthography, the conventions of language.
About three million Brexit coins will enter circulation around the UK from Friday, with a further seven million to be added later in the year.
Prime Minister Boris Johnson is likely to receive one of the first coins later this week, his official spokesman said.
The spokesman told reporters “I’m sure he would wish to keep one” as a souvenir.
The symbolism of the coin, as well as its punctuation, has provoked strong opinions, with Tony Blair’s former spin doctor Alastair Campbell saying: “I for one shall be asking shopkeepers for ‘two 20p pieces and a 10’ if they offer me a 50p coin pretending that Brexit is about ‘peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations’ given it puts all three at risk.”
But the Prime Minister’s spokesman said: “This is not the first time that we have issued a coin to mark an important moment in Britain’s history and culture, we have a long tradition of doing so.
“I would obviously point you to the message that is on the coin, which reads ‘peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations’.”
